Help us improve your experience.

Let us know what you think.

Do you have time for a two-minute survey?

 
 

Appendix

This appendix provides the reference table information from the Results Summary and Analysis sections.

Table 1: Subscriber Traffic Convergence Time Single BNG Failure
BNG1 Failure
Event Services Stream Name (Left Right) Convergence time (ms)
BNG1 failover

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_R_L

28233

26543

28259

26606

19652

19752

18347

17299

19733

21064

4731

22935

21338

7677

3957

6789

BNG Restoration

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_R_L

28200

27541

28246

27615

25111

25153

22457

23457

13627

15057

421

15671

14228

84

50

80

Table 2: Subscriber Traffic Convergence Time Dual BNG Failures
BNG1 and BNG2 Failure
Event Services Stream Name (Left Right) Convergence time (ms)
BNG1 & BNG2 failover

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_R_L

73634

73835

73759

73962

80061

80364

81714

81943

75157

75452

75346

75934

74200

73200

44052

45386

38592

40206

27912

44052

45386

38592

40206

26421

27912

24300

25400

BNG2 Restoration

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_R_L

61457

63551

61563

63661

60142

60356

62058

62300

55979

59446

58219

61268

54200

54300

64214

72004

64999

74329

49419

49419

34675

32425

31676

33962

15

77

48100

20

BNG1 Restoration

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_R_L

62201

64899

61444

65103

67695

70784

65200

70200

19229

20909

60

21261

19503

80

50

70

Table 3: Subscriber Traffic Convergence Time Switch to AN Node Link Failure
SW1 Switch Failure Towards AN Node
Event Services Stream Name (Left Right) Convergence time ms
SW1-AN1 link down

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

7.7

7.7

6.6

1.1

1.2

0.7

0.7

6.9

0

0

0

0

SW1-AN1 link up

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

103

103

90

0

0

0

0

80

0

0

0

0

SW3-AN2 link down

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

833

833

833

833

SW2-AN3 link up

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

59.4

0

57.4

0

61.9

0

61.9

0

18.9

18.9

29.1

28.9

Table 4: Subscriber Traffic Convergence Time AN Node Failure
AN Node Failure
Event Services Stream Name (Left Right) Convergence time ms
AN1 Node Failure

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

100

100

98.4

119.7

114.6

119.5

125.7

96.9

0

0

0

0

AN1 Node restore

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

84

84

84

0

0

0

0

76

0

0

0

0

AN2 Node failure

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

10.4

10.4

10.8

142.5

145.3

147.6

152.6

11.9

372.8

372.8

372.8

372.8

AN2 Node restore

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

30

30

33

0

0

0

0

32

29

28

28

28

AN3 Node failure

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

10.6

152.1

9.2

152.3

9

152.6

9

152.3

327.4

327.4

327.4

327.3

AN3 node restore

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

29.7

0

23.6

0

29

0

29

0

17.6

17.6

27

28.2

Table 5: Subscriber Traffic Convergence Time AN Node to AGN Node Link Failure
AN Link Failure
Event Services Stream Name (Left Right) Convergence time ms
AN1 to AGN1 down

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

AN1 to AGN1 up

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

PPPoEV6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW1_L_R

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW1_L_R

PPPoEV6_FXC_SW1_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW1_L_R

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

AN3 to AGN1 down

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

AN3 to AGN1 up

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv4_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_VPWS_SW2_R_L

PPPoEv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

PPPoEv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv6_FXC_SW2_L_R

DHCPv4_FXC_SW2_L_R

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5

0.5